DEBATELAB Does God Exist?
ACTIVE DISCUSSION

Argument from Contingency

Defend your position naturally. Inspect objections, save notes, explore connected material, or ask AIG without leaving the current discussion.

SESSION PROGRESS 38%
MODE
LIVE
NORA BENNETT SKEPTIC · INTERMEDIATE

I understand that you think the universe needs an explanation, but why couldn't the universe itself simply be the necessary thing? Why introduce God at all?

YOU YOUR RESPONSE

Because the universe appears to contain changing and contingent states. If its existence depends on conditions that could have been otherwise, it doesn't seem to contain the sufficient reason for its own existence.

NORA BENNETT FOLLOW-UP

But aren't you assuming that every contingent thing needs an explanation? Maybe reality simply bottoms out in a brute fact.

YOU RESPONSE

Calling something a brute fact doesn't explain it. The question is whether contingent reality can terminate the explanatory chain when its own state could have been otherwise.

NORA BENNETT FOLLOW-UP

Then what would actually make an explanation ultimate? At some point, don't you still have to stop asking why?